Did a Cow Really Start the Great Chicago Fire? Examining the Myth


The Great Chicago Fire of 1871 was one of the most devastating fires in American history. The fire burned for two days, destroying over 17,000 structures and claiming the lives of at least 300 people. While there have been many theories about what caused the fire, one of the most enduring is that a cow kicked over a lantern in a barn, igniting the blaze. But is there any truth to this popular myth?

The story goes that on October 8, 1871, a cow owned by a woman named Catherine O'Leary kicked over a lantern in the barn where she was milking. The lantern then set fire to the barn, and the flames quickly spread to nearby buildings. However, there is little evidence to support this theory.

For starters, there were multiple fires burning in Chicago on the night of October 8. The city was experiencing a drought, and the weather was unseasonably warm, making conditions ripe for fires to start and spread. While the fire may have started in the O'Leary barn, it's unlikely that a single incident could have caused the massive blaze that engulfed the city.

In fact, the O'Leary family themselves denied that their cow was responsible for the fire. In a statement to the Chicago Tribune, Patrick O'Leary, Catherine's son, said, "I deny that our cow had anything to do with starting the fire. I am positive she did not kick over a lantern. The lantern was hung on a nail on the west side of the barn."

Despite the lack of evidence, the story of the cow and the lantern persists in popular culture. It has been immortalized in books, movies, and even a musical. But it's important to remember that myths like this can obscure the true causes and lessons of historical events.

The Great Chicago Fire was a tragedy that resulted from a combination of factors, including drought, high winds, and a lack of proper firefighting resources. While we may never know exactly how the fire started, it's clear that it was not the result of a single cow's misstep.


Next Post »